Comments on Thank God It's Pie-day: Shaker Lemon Pie

I lied I lied!! Go to: http://allrecipes.com//Reci...

2010-08-10T17:03:54.771-06:00

I lied I lied!! Go to: http://allrecipes.com//Recipe/shaker-lemon-pie/Detail.aspx

That's the right recipe :) The other one calls for cream which kind of detracts from the whole "simple and only 3 ingredients" point of the pie.

It sounds like you made this the same way I did, b...

2010-08-10T15:32:20.881-06:00

It sounds like you made this the same way I did, but we LOVED it... even my 3 year old ate some and it was gone within 12 hours.

I didn't use Martha's recipe though... she calls for a TON of eggs.

I found mine in Southern Living but the same recipe is here: http://find.myrecipes.com/recipes/recipefinder.dyn?action=displayRecipe&recipe_id=1842321

If you feel the urge to try one more time, definitely wait for Meyer Lemons!

That's sad, and too bad about your Shaker Lemo...

2010-04-21T21:39:58.955-06:00

That's sad, and too bad about your Shaker Lemon Pie. I know what you mean about the disappointment. The idea of it had my mouth watering.

Funny thing, though. I usually think Martha Stewart's recipes are at least trustworthy, if not delicious. Yet, just this week I've also had a failure with one of hers, a carrot cupcake recipe. Neither tasty nor pretty; just a flop.